MyFirstCar
← Back to Blog
Buying a Car

New vs. Used: Which Makes More Sense for Your First Car?

MyFirstCar Team · · 5 min read

So you’re buying your first car. Congrats — that’s a big deal! But before you start browsing shiny new models on the dealer’s website, there’s a question worth asking: should you buy new or used?

It’s one of the most debated topics in the car world, and honestly, the answer depends on your situation. But we’ll give you the full picture — the real numbers, the trade-offs, and our honest take — so you can make the call that’s right for you.

The Case for Buying New

Let’s start with the appealing stuff, because new cars are appealing.

You Get the Latest Everything

A brand-new car comes with the newest safety features, the latest tech, and that unmistakable new-car smell. We’re talking adaptive cruise control, lane-keep assist, Apple CarPlay/Android Auto, and crash ratings that keep getting better every year.

Full Manufacturer Warranty

When you buy new, you’re covered. Most manufacturers offer a bumper-to-bumper warranty for 3 years/36,000 miles and a powertrain warranty for 5 years/60,000 miles. If something breaks, it’s their problem, not yours.

No Mystery History

You know exactly how this car has been treated: by nobody, because you’re the first owner. No wondering if the previous owner skipped oil changes or drove it through a flood.

Better Financing Rates

New cars typically qualify for lower interest rates. We’re talking 4-6% APR for new vs. 7-10% for used (depending on your credit). On a $25,000 loan over 60 months, that’s the difference between about $460/month and $495/month. Over the life of the loan, you’d save roughly $2,100 in interest.

The Case for Buying Used

Here’s where things get interesting — and where your wallet starts to smile.

Depreciation Is the Big One

This is the single biggest reason used cars make more financial sense. A new car loses roughly 20% of its value the moment you drive it off the lot. By the end of year one, it’s lost about 25-30%. After three years? You’re looking at 40-50% depreciation.

Let’s put real numbers on that. You buy a new car for $30,000. After one year, it’s worth about $22,500. After three years, maybe $16,500. You just lost $13,500 in value — and that’s on top of your monthly payments.

Now, if you’d bought that same car as a 3-year-old used model for $16,500, it would be worth about $12,000 after three more years. You’d lose $4,500 instead of $13,500. That’s a $9,000 difference.

Lower Insurance Costs

Insurance premiums are based partly on your car’s value. A car worth $16,000 costs less to insure than one worth $30,000 — often 15-25% less. For a young driver already facing high premiums, that difference adds up fast. We’re talking $200-400 per year in savings.

More Car for Your Money

With a used car budget of $15,000, you can get a 2-3 year old vehicle that was originally $25,000+. That means better features, a nicer trim level, and more car than you’d get buying new at the same price point.

Lower Registration Fees

In many states, registration fees are based on the car’s value and age. A used car can save you $100-300 per year on registration alone.

But What About Reliability?

This is the big concern people have about used cars, and it’s valid. But here’s the thing: modern cars are incredibly reliable. A well-maintained 3-5 year old car with 30,000-60,000 miles on it has a lot of life left.

The key is buying smart:

  • Get a vehicle history report (Carfax or AutoCheck). Look for accidents, flood damage, and service records.
  • Get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent mechanic. This costs $100-200 and is worth every penny.
  • Stick to reliable brands. Toyota, Honda, Mazda, and Hyundai/Kia consistently top reliability rankings.
  • Consider certified pre-owned (CPO). These are inspected by the dealer and come with extended warranties. They cost a bit more than regular used, but less than new.

The Numbers Side-by-Side

Let’s compare two scenarios for a first-time buyer:

Buying New: $28,000 sedan

  • Down payment (10%): $2,800
  • Loan amount: $25,200 at 5.5% APR for 60 months = $481/month
  • Insurance (young driver): ~$2,400/year ($200/month)
  • First-year depreciation loss: ~$7,000
  • Total first-year cost: ~$15,570

Buying Used: Same model, 3 years old, $16,000

  • Down payment (10%): $1,600
  • Loan amount: $14,400 at 7.5% APR for 48 months = $348/month
  • Insurance (young driver): ~$1,900/year ($158/month)
  • First-year depreciation loss: ~$2,000
  • Total first-year cost: ~$9,676

That’s nearly $6,000 in savings the first year alone.

When Buying New Actually Makes Sense

We’re not going to pretend used is always the answer. Here are times when new might be the better call:

  • You’re keeping it 10+ years. If you plan to drive this car into the ground, the depreciation hit matters less over time.
  • You want specific safety features. If the latest collision avoidance tech gives you peace of mind (especially for a teen driver), that’s worth something.
  • There’s a killer incentive. Manufacturers sometimes offer 0% APR or massive rebates that close the gap with used pricing.
  • You can’t find the right used car. In tight used markets (like we saw in 2021-2023), the price difference between new and used can shrink significantly.

Our Honest Take

For most first-time car buyers, a 2-4 year old used car is the sweet spot. You dodge the worst of depreciation, save on insurance, and still get a modern, reliable vehicle with plenty of life ahead of it.

A first car is going to get some door dings, maybe a curb-rashed wheel, and definitely some french fries in the seat cracks. That stuff stings a lot less on a $15,000 car than a $30,000 one.

The Bottom Line

  • New cars offer peace of mind, the latest features, and better financing — but you pay a steep premium for depreciation.
  • Used cars save you thousands upfront and in ongoing costs, with minimal sacrifice in reliability if you buy smart.
  • For a first car, used is usually the smarter financial move. Save the new car purchase for when you’ve got a few years of driving (and saving) under your belt.

Whatever you decide, the most important thing is buying a car you can comfortably afford — one that won’t stress your budget every month. Because the best first car is the one that gets you where you need to go without keeping you up at night.

Keeping track of your car’s maintenance and costs is a lot easier with the right tools. MyFirstCar helps you stay on top of everything from oil changes to insurance — so you can focus on actually enjoying the ride. Check it out →